About
That’s Fishy is a fish and chip shop in Casula that has built a loyal following over many years, with regulars returning week after week for the fresh seafood and made-to-order meals. The battered fish is a firm favourite, served with a homemade tartare sauce that long-time visitors tend to single out, and the calamari draws consistent praise alongside it. Meals are prepared fresh to order, so wait times can be a little longer than a standard takeaway, though most regulars consider that a fair trade-off for the quality on the plate.
The menu suits a range of tastes and budgets, with portion sizes and pricing that compare well against more formal seafood restaurants in the area. Dine-in, takeaway, and delivery are all available, making That’s Fishy a practical option for families across the Casula area. The venue is family-friendly and wheelchair-accessible, with free parking on site.
It is worth noting that recent feedback has raised some concerns around service consistency, so experiences can vary. The shop is open for lunch and dinner, and phone-ahead orders can help during busy periods.
Business Hours
Dine-In Available?
Map
Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.
Sorry, unable to load the Maps API.
Photo
8 Reviews on “That's Fishy”
Ordered from Uber a seafood platter for 1 and the food was SO GOOD! The freshest seafood I’ve ever had delivered via Uber. The salmon tacos were delicious too. Definitely ordering again. 10/10
Great food and everything was fresh served hot and cooked on order.
Some of the girls behind the counter are just rude we’re trying rush us to order while we still picking and looking at the menu.
Like obviously when we’re ready, will order it’s not a fine dining so relax.
also the the daily specially is pricy for what it is considering the fish and salad is $18.9 and once u add the chips it goes to $30 ridiculous
THERE IS A REASON THIS PLACE HAS BEEN THERE FOR OVER 25 YEARS. me and my family come here every week and have never had a bad meal. Always top quality food and great service. you can just tell the owners have a passion for what they do. We got one of the platters this week, SENSATIONAL.
The best seafood around, I’ve been going to that’s fishy for years now and nothing compares. For what you would pay at a high end restaurant, you can get the exact same quality, taste and a bigger portion for a fraction of the price. I come here with my family and we always order platters with large calamari, prawns and octopus and have never been disappointed. Not to mention I have always received friendly service with a smile.
I waited to be served about seven minutes before they attended. It wasn’t even busy, Monday night. And then I made my order for a chicken nuggets and chips. Their printer wasnt working. then it took them about a good 10-15 minutes to make the food, despite it wasnt a busy time. And then I asked if they could put in a takeaway container. They told me it is takeaway, but I asked for something with a lid. They initially told me they dont have until i pointed to a box. They said thats for Uber. I offered to pay them. They agreed then charged me $1 for a box with no plastic bag. the serving lady had no smile whatso ever.
The seafood is fresh and all the meals are delicious. There’s several reviews that the food takes a while, and that’s because everything is made to order. You cannot expect freshness without a small compromise.
10/10 this is our go to fish and chips.
Rude and unhygienic. After paying for salad and drink the young man passed me a fork bare-handed, unwrapped
I then asked for a straw because I did not see any. The same man reached into an open container and picked up a PLASTIC straw…unwrapped and with bare hands.I said I could not put that in my drink after he had handled it. He very rudely said I should have got my own. When I asked for a refund he called the older man over who said he could not do it and said he would call security
They have been reported to the health dept. !
PS……I am almost 80 years old. Is this why the owner was so rude? Shame on you
He is even rude in his responses to other people’s criticism
What happened to “sorry, let me do it better next time”. No, he is so arrogant he will not admit he was wrong
I have a bad experience to this shop the lady that serves my orders was so rude she did not say anything even thank you or smile I did not get a warm welcome she is unprofessional its is my first time to buy my seafood dinner and I will never come back here again. Food is tasteless highly not recommended.